Home > Things to Do > Dining

Dining

Filter Your Search

Too much to taste on a single trip

Would you like to experience dining in an Amish home? Eager to get your fill of home cooking with our family-style dining? Or maybe you’re just looking forward to a great slice of pizza. Whatever flavors you enjoy, don’t forget to leave room for a slice of pie! Browse through our dining options to find a great place to eat in Shipshewana/LaGrange County.

Ben's Bakery

Ben's Bakery

Stop by our family owned Bakery and try some of our Homemade Goodies like our delicious Fried Pies with a flaky crust oozing with our own homemade fruit filling, made with real fruit or try our Famous Whoopie Pies with fluffy vanilla frosting in the ...more

T: 260-768-4174 

Ben's Soft Pretzels

Ben's Soft Pretzels

Famous Amish hand rolled, soft pretzels. Delicious pizza, ham and cheese, swiss dog pockets, Amish peanut butter, and jams. 9 am to 4 pm Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday & Saturday.

Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery Make a Reservation

Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery

Since opening in 1986 with 50 seats, the Blue Gate's great food and service has helped it become a cornerstone of Shipshewana. Serving up their famous home-style Amish favorites in beautiful downtown Shipshewana. Dine family-style or from the menu ...more

T: 260-768-4725  | W: View Website

Amish Frozen Custard & Ice Cream

Amish Frozen Custard & Ice Cream

Serving our rich, creamy frozen custard and famous soft serve ice-cream specialties for over 20 years. Ask about the flavor of the week. Malts, shakes, flurries, smoothies, waffle cones, cups, banana splits, pop, and other specialties. Buses and ...more

T: 260-768-7770  | W: View Website

Bread Box Bakery & Café

Bread Box Bakery & Café

Amish baked flaky crust pies, breads, cookies, huge cinnamon rolls, etc. For lunch enjoy a homemade Panini with soup and brewed iced tea in our outdoor garden dining area or in the Century home of Shipshewana's founder. Bus groups are welcome to ...more

T: 260-768-4629  | W: View Website

Next Door Neighbor Deli & Bakery

Next Door Neighbor Deli & Bakery

Located on a working farm between Middlebury & Shipshewana on SR 120. Our full line of bakery items is baked daily on site. Featuring Fruitcakes by Deb, Jumbo Cinnamon Rolls, Sausage Bread and Cashew Butter Bars. Breakfast and lunch served 6 days a ...more

T: 574-825-1716  | W: View Website

Shipshewana Auction Restaurant

Shipshewana Auction Restaurant

Take a break from Flea Market shopping with a delicious Amish meal, quick sandwich and homemade pie. Wed. 7am-7pm, Fri. 7am-2pm (Tues. 6am-7pm May-Oct.)

T: 260-768-4129  | E: info@tradingplaceamerica.com | W: View Website

Chicago Joe's

Chicago Joe's

Come try a "Taste of Chicago" homemade pizza, Italian beef, sausage, and meatball sandwiches. Chicago dogs, gyros, polish, and fresh-cut fries. Beer and wine.

T: 260-499-5637  | E: cherylalbergo@embarqmail.com

Crossroads Cafe

Crossroads Cafe

Enjoy the local flavor of the Soda Fountain, offering a variety of breakfast and lunch options, ice cream, and homemade pie. Mon-Sat 5:30am-4pm

T: 260-593-2252  | W: View Website

Amish Acres Historic Farm & Heritage Resort

Amish Acres Historic Farm & Heritage Resort

America's Complete Amish Heritage experience. Explore Amish Acres 80-acre farm featuring historic interpretation through guided tours of the only Old Order Amish farm listed in the National Register of Historic Places. Enjoy live musical theatre and ...more

T: 800-800-4942  | W: View Website

Emma Cafe & Catering, Inc.

Emma Cafe & Catering, Inc.

1930's Soda Fountain, Soups, Salads, Sandwiches, Daily Specials, Pizza, Bakery items, Ice Cream, Frozen Yogurt Bar, Banquet Room Available, Classic Car Cruise-in.

T: 260-593-9025  | E: molly@emmacafeandcatering.com | W: View Website

JoJo's Pretzels

JoJo's Pretzels

Famous for our hand rolled soft pretzels. JoJo's, a "must experience" on your visit. Piping hot pretzels, homemade mustards! Celebrating over 20 years in Shipshewana.

T: 260-768-7759  | E: levijojo@aol.com | W: View Website

KuKuis Hawaiian Shave Ice

KuKuis Hawaiian Shave Ice

Experience a taste of authentic Hawaiian shave ice. 30 flavors. Kalua Pig pulled pork, Hawaiian nachos, Pineapple slaw, 100% Kona Coffee, ice cream. "its NOT a snow cone!"

T: 260-768-4383  | E: cindy@kukuis.com | W: View Website

Pumpkinvine Cafe

Pumpkinvine Cafe

Shipshewana's newest cafe featuring specialty coffees, sandwiches, soups and desserts. Enjoy free WiFi while relaxing by the fireplace or by the window overlooking historic downtown.

T: 260-768-3125 

Red Bud Gift Shop & Coffee Tea Cafe'

Red Bud Gift Shop & Coffee Tea Cafe'

Enjoy Lunch! Red Bud specialty sandwich, homemade soup and apple dumpling; or a pot of tea, scones, luncheon tea, and tea parties! Lots of fudge to sample or buy!

T: 260-768-3013  | W: View Website

The Hitching Post Frozen Yogurt & Coffee Bar

The Hitching Post Frozen Yogurt & Coffee Bar

With 12 delicious flavors of frozen yogurt and 55+ toppings, the NEW Hitching Post is a sweet spot to visit. Also with a full service specialty coffee bar.

T: 260-768-4725  | W: View Website

Wana Cup Restaurant

Wana Cup Restaurant

We feature a large menu of delicious home-cooked meals, pies and homemade ice cream. Open for breakfast. We also have pizza! Delivery Available.

T: 260-768-4923  | E: wanacup@hotmail.com

East of Chicago Pizza

East of Chicago Pizza

Open 7 days, Lunch and Dinner Buffet with pizza, subs, salad bar, and more at Family Friendly prices. Deliver and Carry out also available.

T: 260-768-7272  | W: View Website

Country Corral Restaurant

Country Corral Restaurant

Serving the best breakfast in town! Daily lunch specials- Open 5am-2pm

T: 260-768-4589 

Garden Gate Café

Garden Gate Café

Located on Morton Street, we have homemade soups, salads, Paninis and wraps. Come in and enjoy our delightful atmosphere. Open Monday-Saturday 9am to 4pm. Off season hours vary.

T: 260-768-7675  | E: thegardengatecafe@yahoo.com | W: View Website

Dairy Queen

Dairy Queen

Pumpkinvine Bike Trail access from our parking lot. Enjoy our full food, treat and drink menu including Chicken Strip Baskets, Blizzards and Orange Julius Beverages.

T: 574-825-5222  | E: dqlovers@maplenet.net | W: View Website

Howe Family Restaurant

Howe Family Restaurant

Winter Hours: 6am-9pm Monday-Saturday, 6am-8pm Sunday. Summer Hours: 6am-10pm Monday-Saturday, 6am-9pm Sunday. Relax and let us do the cooking! Free WiFi, breakfast served all day, senior menu, daily specials, carry out or delivery (15 mile radius) ...more

T: 260-562-3132 

Cindy's Kuntry Dining

Cindy's Kuntry Dining

Welcome to Cindy's! Relax and enjoy Amish home-style cooking and Harry's Homemade Ice Cream for any occasion. Choose from several different meals. Reservations required. Buses and any size group welcome!

T: 260-350-8743 

M & L Acres

M & L Acres

For a One-of-a-kind home-cooked dining experience, call M & L Acres. We offer cooking demonstrations and homemade salsa, ketchup,sweet mustard's, breads and more! Reservations required.

T: 260-768-3248 

Care's Banquets

Care's Banquets

Experience delicious Amish Home-Style cooking and homemade pies at Care's! Small groups from 6 to 35 people welcome! Book your Holiday and Birthday parties here!

T: 260-350-4969 

The Carriage House

The Carriage House

"Discover Our Best!" Welcoming atmosphere, homemade food and friendly service created by a family team. Quilting bees, cinnamon roll and cooking demonstrations. Reservations required.

T: 260-768-8199 

Yoder's Homestyle Cooking LLC

Yoder's Homestyle Cooking LLC

Our 14th year of service to our guests with Family Dining on our farm. Thresher's- Haystack- Soup/Salad- Breakfast. Cooking classes available. Reservations Required! 15 or more.

T: 260-768-3078 

Red Bud Gift Shop & Coffee Tea Cafe'

Red Bud Gift Shop & Coffee Tea Cafe'

Choose a special hand decorated Teapot, Cup/Saucer and more. Select your favorite loose tea. 100 plus kinds! Or have a cup of tea while shopping!

T: 260-768-3013  | W: View Website

Topeka Pharmacy * Sara's Attic

Topeka Pharmacy * Sara's Attic

Located 9 miles South of Shipshewana, Topeka Pharmacy offers gifts, collectibles, fabrics, floral, Soda Fountain and more! Pharmacy: Weekdays 8am-6pm, Sat til 5pm Cafe; Weekdays 5:30 am-4pm

T: 260-593-2252  | W: View Website

5 & 20 Country Restaurant

5 & 20 Country Restaurant

Located at the corner of SR 5 & US 20 This local favorite restaurant offers menu style dining or Salad bar and buffet dining. Open Monday thru Saturday

T: 260-768-4958 

Adams Lake Pub

Adams Lake Pub

Thank you for nominating us for lake restaurant of the year! Adams Lake Pub located just north of Kendallville, Indiana is a contemporary family owned and operated restaurant. From the front of the house to the back of the house we care, it's from ...more

T: 260-854-3463  | W: View Website

Coody Browns

Coody Browns

Coody Browns Bar & Grill welcome everyone! Stop on in for some of our famous Coody Fries - daily specials! Located between Witmer and Westler Lakes - see you there!

T: 260-854-2425 

Das Dutchman Essenhaus

Das Dutchman Essenhaus

Since 1971, Das Dutchman Essenhaus has been "A Pleasant Surprise in Amish Country". Leisurely stroll across the colorful campus; discover Indiana's largest family restaurant where family-style, buffet and menu dining options are each prepared using ...more

T: 574-825-9471  | W: View Website

El Zorrito

El Zorrito

Authentic Mexican Food & American Breakfast Daily Lunch Specials Come & Enjoy the Chimi Acapulco!

T: 260-593-0173 

El Zorrito 2 - Shipshewana

El Zorrito 2 - Shipshewana

Are you hungry? Stop in for some delicious Mexican cuisine at EL Zorrito 2 in Shipshewana, Indiana. We will have our Grand Opening on August 16, 2013. So tell everyone you know to stop by and get some fresh, hot Mexican Food........ See you all soon.

T: 260-768-4447 

Fireside Cafe

Fireside Cafe

300 S Van Buren Street (Inside Yoder's Shopping Center) Featuring in-house smoked meats and beans for our sandwiches, salads and wraps! We also offer a variety of made-from-scratch sides and locally roasted hot and iced coffees. Finish your meal with ...more

T: 260-768-3473  | W: View Website

Foltz Bakery

Foltz Bakery

Freshly baked goods - donuts - breads - cookies and more! Yummy! Hours: Monday thru Friday 5:30 am to 4:30 pm Saturday 5:30 am to 2:30 pm *CLOSED ON SUNDAY*

T: 260-463-3423 

Golden Buddha-Howe

Golden Buddha-Howe

Located just North off I80/90 Toll Road - delicious Chinese & American food

T: 260-562-2646 

Grossman's Restaurant & Lounge

Grossman's Restaurant & Lounge

New Menus at Grossman's. New Items include a Southsider Sandwich, Spinach and Artichoke Dip, Bacon Cheese Chips, and Top Sirloin. Come in and see all the new additions. Plenty of food, fun and entertainment! See you soon!

T: 260-499-3393  | E: tcriegling@embarqmail.com | W: View Website

Happiness Is Ice Cream

Happiness Is Ice Cream

Come to an ice cream shop that knows how to serve ice cream. Large cones, smooth shakes, great sundaes, huge waffle cones and root beer floats. Of course we also serve banana splits that are so big they can replace a meal.

T: 260-562-2311  | W: View Website

Hometown Family Restaurant

Hometown Family Restaurant

Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner. Many daily specials, smoke-free 7 days weekly.

T: 260-463-7050 

Iannarelli's Italian Restaurant

Iannarelli's Italian Restaurant

Our recipes are authentic and handed down through the family. Come in and enjoy a delicious meal in our friendly and relaxed dining rooms. Classic Car Cruise Ins every Tuesday

T: 260-562-2500  | E: tjiannarelli@embarqmail.com | W: View Website

Lucy's Vedie-Twist

Lucy's Vedie-Twist

Sweet Treats! Food! and more! Stop in and see us Hours: Seasonal

T: 260-463-3868 

Marner's Six Mile

Marner's Six Mile

Smile God Loves You! But Don't Be Caught Dead Without Jesus! Enjoy home-cooked food at its best! Monday thru Fiday4:30 am to 2:00 pm, Saturday 4:30 am to 10:00 am.

T: 260-463-2381  | E: pbmarner@hotmail.com

McDonalds

McDonalds

Located south of downtown LaGrange on SR 9 Open 7 days a week!

Pizza Hut Italian Bistro

Pizza Hut Italian Bistro

Delicious Pizza, Pasta, Wings and more! Open Sundays

T: 260-463-3164  | W: View Website

Rise 'N Roll Bakery & Café

Rise 'N Roll Bakery & Café

Home of the original Crunch Candies; cashew, chocolate cashew, pecan and nutty. Always serving FREE coffee and samples. Half way between Shipshewana and Middlebury on US 20.

T: 574-825-4032  | E: customerservice@risenrollbakery.com | W: View Website

Subway - LaGrange

Subway - LaGrange

Catering for all occasions! Business meetings, group activities, church & youth groups, sports and/or club events, celebrations & holidays.

T: 260-463-7224 

Subway - Shipshewana

Subway - Shipshewana

Open Monday thru Sunday

T: 260-768-4313 

The Gathering Place

The Gathering Place

Home-Cooked meals without all the work! Hours: Mon-Thurs 6 am to 7 pm Friday 6 am to 8 pm Saturday 6 am to 7 pm

T: 260-562-3584 

The Woods Too Restaurant

The Woods Too Restaurant

The Woods Too and Lighthouse Lounge, formerly Lake of the Woods has been family owned and operated for over 30 years. We love to have fun, entertain, and prepare excellent seafood dishes - we also have outstanding steaks and smoke house favorites!

T: 260-351-2967 

Tiffany's Restaurant

Tiffany's Restaurant

Tiffany's is a must when you visit the Amish Backroads and there is one thing you'll experience; warm hospitality and mouth-watering, home cooked meals for which the region is so well known. So stop in and enjoy a meal that will leave you completely ...more

T: 260-593-2988 

Townline Community Center Homestyle Dinner

Townline Community Center Homestyle Dinner

Enjoy delicious Amish cooking at the home of Nora Bontrager! Homemade pies, breads and much more await you and your group.

T: 260-768-4425 

Woodside Diner LLC

Woodside Diner LLC

Delicious home-cooking served Family-Style at Woodside Diner. This Amish in Home dining experience is sure to tempt your pallet! Serving the Traditional "Amish Wedding Fest", Haystack, and Thresher's Meal all with mouth-watering pies. Reservations ...more

T: 260-499-4230